The progress in seismic acquisition techniques characterized by wide azimuths,wide frequency bands,and high densities has greatly promoted the application of the prestack P-wave fracture inversion technique based on the azimuthal anisotropy theory.Azimuthal anisotropy-based inversion can yield the azimuths and intensities of fractures.However,different inversion techniques yield different parameters for fracture intensity characterization,resulting in inconsistent inversion results.Consequently,the azimuthal anisotropy-based inversion results of fractures are non-unique,leading to confusion about accurate results.Based on the Thomsen anisotropy theory,as well as the interrelationships between fracture models(the Hudson coin model and the Schoenberg linear sliding model),this study established the connections of anisotropic parameters between different fracture inversion techniques(VVAZ,Ruger's approximation,and Fourier series),presenting the real meanings and mathematical expressions of results from different azimuthal anisotropy-based fracture inversion techniques.Additionally,this study summarized the relationships of parameters between different inversion techniques and fracture models,further deepening the research on azimuthal anisotropy-based fracture inversion.This study lays solid theoretical and technical foundations for large-scale fracture detection based on the seismic data obtained using the seismic acquisition techniques featuring wide azimuths,wide frequency bands, and high densities.
Keywords:azimuthal anisotropy;
fracture inversion;
VVAZ;
Ruger's approximation;
Fourier series
LIANG Zhi-Qiang, LI Hong. Comparison and summary of different azimuthal anisotropy-based inversion techniques[J]. Geophysical and Geochemical Exploration, 2024, 48(2): 443-450 doi:10.11720/wtyht.2024.1251
0 引言
随着国内外“两宽一高”采集技术的发展和普及,基于宽方位道集的P波方位各向异性裂缝预测技术也越来越成熟[1-2]。P波方位各向异性技术,顾名思义,是基于纵波方位的变化规律来计算各向异性参数;与之相对应的是横波各向异性技术,它是利用快慢横波的分裂来计算各向异性参数的[3-4]。P波方位各向异性技术按地震数据的类型可以分为速度(或者时差[5])和振幅两类:基于P波方位速度变化的技术一般称之为VVAZ(velocity variations with azimuth,速度随方位角变化)[6-7],后来又发展了基于TTI(tilted transverse isotropy,倾斜横向各向同性)介质的方位时差技术[5]等。基于P波方位振幅变化的技术一般称之为AVAZ(amplitude variation with azimuth,振幅随方位角变化),基于AVAZ各向异性反演技术的类型较多,早期为椭圆拟合技术[8];之后又发展了Ruger近似公式[9⇓-11]和方位傅立叶级数反演技术[12];这些年又发展了基于裂缝岩石物理模型的AVAZ反演技术[13-14]等。从基本的公式来说,不同的反演技术由于基于不同的TI介质理论,不同的地震道集数据、技术路线以及反演结果均有所差异:VVAZ反演的结果直接为Thomsen各向异性参数δ来表示裂缝强度;椭圆拟合技术一般以长轴除以短轴为裂缝强度;Ruger近似反演的结果以各向异性梯度来表示,而方位傅立叶级数反演的各向异性梯度又与Ruger近似反演的各向异性梯度并不完全相同,因此就造成了裂缝各向异性反演结果的不唯一性,进而造成谁才是“正确的”这种困惑和疑问[15]。本文从最基础的Thomsen各向异性基本理论出发[16],通过分析不同裂缝介质的简化模型(Hudson薄币模型[17]、Schoenberg线性滑动模型[18]),在不同的裂缝反演技术(VVAZ、Ruger近似和傅立叶级数)之间建立各向异性的参数联系,给出了每一个方位各向异性裂缝反演结果的真实含义和数学表达,并对不同反演技术与裂缝模型参数之间的联系进行了总结,进一步深化方位各向异性裂缝反演的研究,为基于“两宽一高”数据开展大规模的裂缝定量检测奠定了坚实的理论和技术基础。
Transverse isotropy with a horizontal axis of symmetry (HTI) is the simplest azimuthally anisotropic model used to describe fractured reservoirs that contain parallel vertical cracks. Here, I present an exact equation for normal‐moveout (NMO) velocities from horizontal reflectors valid for pure modes in HTI media with any strength of anisotropy. The azimuthally dependent P‐wave NMO velocity, which can be obtained from 3-D surveys, is controlled by the principal direction of the anisotropy (crack orientation), the P‐wave vertical velocity, and an effective anisotropic parameter equivalent to Thomsen's coefficient δ. An important parameter of fracture systems that can be constrained by seismic data is the crack density, which is usually estimated through the shear‐wave splitting coefficient γ. The formalism developed here makes it possible to obtain the shear‐wave splitting parameter using the NMO velocities of P and shear waves from horizontal reflectors. Furthermore, γ can be estimated just from the P‐wave NMO velocity in the special case of the vanishing parameter ε, corresponding to thin cracks and negligible equant porosity. Also, P‐wave moveout alone is sufficient to constrain γ if either dipping events are available or the velocity in the symmetry direction is known. Determination of the splitting parameter from P‐wave data requires, however, an estimate of the ratio of the P‐to‐S vertical velocities (either of the split shear waves can be used). Velocities and polarizations in the vertical symmetry plane of HTI media, that contains the symmetry axis, are described by the known equations for vertical transverse isotropy (VTI). Time‐related 2-D P‐wave processing (NMO, DMO, time migration) in this plane is governed by the same two parameters (the NMO velocity from a horizontal reflector and coefficient ε) as in media with a vertical symmetry axis. The analogy between vertical and horizontal transverse isotropy makes it possible to introduce Thomsen parameters of the “equivalent” VTI model, which not only control the azimuthally dependent NMO velocity, but also can be used to reconstruct phase velocity and carry out seismic processing in off‐symmetry planes.
PechA, TsvankinI, GrechkaV.
Quartic moveout coefficient:3D description and application to tilted TI media
Nonhyperbolic (long‐spread) moveout provides essential information for a number of seismic inversion/processing applications, particularly for parameter estimation in anisotropic media. Here, we present an analytic expression for the quartic moveout coefficient A4that controls the magnitude of nonhyperbolic moveout of pure (nonconverted) modes. Our result takes into account reflection‐point dispersal on irregular interfaces and is valid for arbitrarily anisotropic, heterogeneous media. All quantities needed to compute A4can be evaluated during the tracing of the zero‐offset ray, so long‐spread moveout can be modeled without time‐consuming multioffset, multiazimuth ray tracing.
RügerA.Reflection coefficients and azimuthal AVO analysis in anisotropic media[D]. Center for Wave Phenomena,Colorado School of Mines,1996.
ChenH Z.Study on methodology of pre-stack seismic inversion for fractured reservoirs based on rock physics[D]. Qingdao: China University of Petroleum(East China), 2015.
Most bulk elastic media are weakly anisotropic. The equations governing weak anisotropy are much simpler than those governing strong anisotropy, and they are much easier to grasp intuitively. These equations indicate that a certain anisotropic parameter (denoted δ) controls most anisotropic phenomena of importance in exploration geophysics, some of which are nonnegligible even when the anisotropy is weak. The critical parameter δ is an awkward combination of elastic parameters, a combination which is totally independent of horizontal velocity and which may be either positive or negative in natural contexts.
HudsonJ A.
Wave speeds and attenuation of elastic waves in material containing cracks
[J]. Geophysical Journal of the Royal Astronomical Society, 1981, 64(1):133-150.
A model for an imperfectly bonded interface between two elastic media is proposed. Displacement across this surface is not required to be continuous. The displacement discontinuity, or slip, is taken to be linearly related to the stress traction which is continuous across the interface. For isotropic interface behavior, there are two complex frequency dependent interface compliances, ηN and ηT, where the component of the slip normal to the interface is given by ηN times the normal stress and the component tangential to the interface is given by ηT times the shear stress and is in the same direction. Reflection and transmission coefficients for harmonic plane waves incident at arbitrary angles upon a plane linear slip interface are computed in terms of the interface compliances. These coefficients are frequency dependent even when the compliances are real and frequency independent. Examples of the effects of buried slip interfaces on reflection coefficient spectra and on Love-wave dispersion relations are presented.
HsuC J, SchoenbergM.
Elastic waves through a simulated fractured medium
Ultrasonic velocities were measured on a block composed of lucite plates with roughened surfaces pressed together with a static normal stress to simulate a fractured medium. The measurements, normal, parallel, and oblique to the fractures, show that for wavelengths much larger than the thickness of an individual plate, the block can be modeled as a particular type of transversely isotropic (TI) medium that depends on four parameters. This TI medium behavior is the same as that of an isotropic solid in which are embedded a set of parallel linear slip interfaces, specified by (1) the excess compliance tangential to the interfaces and (2) the excess compliance normal to the interfaces. At all static stress levels, we inverted the data for the background isotropic medium parameters and the excess compliances. The background parameters obtained were basically independent of stress level and agreed well with the bulk properties of the lucite. The excess compliances decreased with increasing static closing stress, implying that increasing static stress forces asperities on either side of a fracture into greater contact, gradually eliminating the excess compliance that gives rise to the anisotropy. A medium with such planes of excess compliance has been shown, theoretically, to describe the behavior of a medium with long parallel joints, as well as a medium with embedded parallel microcracks.
SchoenbergM, DoumaJ.
Elastic wave propagation in media with parallel fractures and aligned cracks1
The simplest effective model of a formation containing a single fracture system is transversely isotropic with a horizontal symmetry axis (HTI). Reflection seismic signatures in HTI media, such as NMO velocity and amplitude variation with offset (AVO) gradient, can be conveniently described by the Thomsen‐type anisotropic parameters [Formula: see text] [Formula: see text] and [Formula: see text] Here, we use the linear slip theory of Schoenberg and co‐workers and the models developed by Hudson and Thomsen for pennyshaped cracks to relate the anisotropic parameters to the physical properties of the fracture network and to devise fracture characterization procedures based on surface seismic measurements. Concise expressions for [Formula: see text] [Formula: see text] and [Formula: see text] linearized in the crack density, show a substantial difference between the values of the anisotropic parameters for isolated fluid‐filled and dry (gas‐filled) penny‐sh aped cracks. While the dry‐crack model is close to elliptical with [Formula: see text] for thin fluid‐filled cracks [Formula: see text] and the absolute value of [Formula: see text] for typical [Formula: see text] ratios in the background is close to the crack density. The parameters [Formula: see text] and [Formula: see text] for models with partial saturation or hydraulically connected cracks and pores always lie between the values for dry and isolated fluid‐filled cracks. We also demonstrate that all possible pairs of [Formula: see text] and [Formula: see text] occupy a relatively narrow triangular area in the [Formula: see text] [Formula: see text]plane, which can be used to identify the fracture‐induced HTI model from seismic data. The parameter [Formula: see text] along with the fracture orientation, can be obtained from the P-wave NMO ellipse for a horizontal reflector. Given [Formula: see text] the NMO velocity of a dipping event or nonhyperbolic moveout can be inverted for [Formula: see text] The remaining anisotropic coefficient, [Formula: see text] can be determined from the constraint on the parameters of vertically fractured HTI media if an estimate of the [Formula: see text] ratio is available. Alternatively, it is possible to find [Formula: see text] by combining the NMO ellipse for horizontal events with the azimuthal variation of the P-wave AVO gradient. Also, we present a concise approximation for the AVO gradient of converted (PS) modes and show that all three relevant anisotropic coefficients of HTI media can be determined by the joint inversion of the AVO gradients or NMO velocities of P- and PS-waves. For purposes of evaluating the properties of the fractures, it is convenient to recalculate the anisotropic coefficients into the normal [Formula: see text] and tangential [Formula: see text] weaknesses of the fracture system. If the HTI model results from penny‐shaped cracks, [Formula: see text] gives a direct estimate of the crack density and the ratio [Formula: see text] is a sensitive indicator of fluid saturation. However, while there is a substantial difference between the values of [Formula: see text] for isolated fluid‐filled cracks and dry cracks, interpretation of intermediate values of [Formula: see text] for porous rocks requires accounting for the hydraulic interaction between cracks and pores.
Azimuthal anisotropy in rocks can result from the presence of one or more sets of partially aligned fractures with orientations determined by the stress history of the rock. The symmetry of a rock with horizontal bedding that contains two or more non‐orthogonal sets of vertical fractures may be approximated as monoclinic with a horizontal plane of mirror symmetry. For offsets that are small compared with the depth of the reflector, the azimuthal variation in P‐wave AVO gradient for such a medium varies with azimuth as where φ is the azimuth measured with respect to the fast polarization direction for a vertically polarized shear wave. φ2 depends on both the normal compliance BN and the shear compliance BT of the fractures and may differ from zero if BNBT varies significantly between fracture sets. If BNBT is the same for all fractures, \n\n and the principal axes of the azimuthal variation in P‐wave AVO for fixed offset are determined by the polarization directions of a vertically propagating shear wave. At larger offsets, terms in \n\n and \n\n are required to describe the azimuthal variation in AVO accurately. φ4 and φ6 also depend on BNBT. For gas‐filled open fractures \n\n but a lower value of BNBT may result from the presence of a fluid with non‐zero bulk modulus.
<FONT face=Verdana>Can we use common fracture growth intensity approximate formula for fracture density evaluation in dip fracture? It is worth for discussion.Starting from reflecting amplitude equation of TTI medium,the fracture density formula of TTI medium was gained,which is similar with that of HTI medium.Through comparison on the two formulas,the basic theory for fracture density calculations varying with its dip was built.Then,by numerical calculation,the relationship curve of fracture density and dip was plotted,and the impact of fracture dip was quantitatively analyzed.The results indicate that in the representative designed model,when fracture dip is smaller than 80°,large deviation will be obtained by evaluating fracture density through simplified approximate formula.The forward modeling results of TTI and HTI medium models designed in terms of fractured reservoirs of Tahe Oilfield prove the above conclusions.Meanwhile,it is found that the impact of fracture dip on its density evaluation is even larger than the error caused by data noise.So,we suggest that it couldnt directly use the simplified formula for fracture density calculation in dip fractured medium.</FONT>